Homemade peanut butter is tastier, healthier, and even cheaper in the long run than the store version.
If you’ve never made peanut butter before, don’t worry. Making your own peanut butter with a blender is easy.
All you need are peanuts (of course), a bit of salt, and a powerful blender for peanuts.
The best blenders for peanut butter are those with a strong motor and a well-thought-out blade design.
You could have the most powerful blender in the world, if the blades suck, the results will be mediocre at best.
In this article, I’m going through the best blenders for peanuts. These blenders come with strong motors and unique blade designs that create perfectly smooth and delicious peanut butter, or any other nut butter you’d like.
The 5 Best Blenders for Peanut Butter
1. Ninja Professional BN701 – Best Blender for Peanuts
If you don’t want to spend a fortune on a blender that can make peanut butter, I got great news for you. With this affordable Ninja Professional Plus Blender it’s pretty easy to make your own peanut butter.
This latest-generation model has a new, modern design and a more powerful motor base. It now features a 1,400-watt motor and comes with smart presets called Auto-iQ.
The Auto-iQ functions are super easy to use. There are presets for smoothies, crushing ice, and ice cream.
You press one button and let the Ninja do its thing. You can literally walk away while your blender does all the work for you.
It automatically runs through different blending cycles, starts and stops the blades on its own. This allows the ingredients to settle and re-mix giving you perfect results every time. No guesswork involved.
Unfortunately, there isn’t a preset for nut butter, but making peanut butter with your Ninja isn’t rocket science.
Simply add peanuts to your blender and start blending on the lowest setting. When the peanuts start turning into creamy nut butter, flip your blender to a higher speed until the peanut butter turned to your desired consistency.
In just a few minutes, you’ll have perfectly smooth peanut butter. You control exactly what’s going in there.
The 72 oz blender jar with 64 oz liquid capacity is great for making large batches of peanut butter for your whole family. The powerful motor runs through peanuts and turns it into smooth or chunky nut butter in seconds.
What I love about the Ninja Professional is the unique blade system. Ninja calls it “Total Crushing Technology”.
Six different blades pointing in every direction liquefy and turn everything into a perfectly smooth consistency. It even crushes ice into snow-like consistency in seconds.
Most other blenders in this price range lack the power to make creamy, smooth peanut butter. For the Ninja it’s an easy job.
Downside to Ninja blenders is the short warranty. You’ll only get a 1-year limited warranty with this blender.
I personally never had any issues with my Ninja, but it’s worth mentioning that some users reported their plastic jar cracking after heavy usage.
If you’re crushing ice cubes, it’s best to start on the lowest setting and gradually turn over to a higher setting, so the ice cubes won’t damage the sides of your blender jar
Cleaning this blender is a breeze.
The blade assembly is removable and you can toss most parts into your dishwasher. Be cautious while cleaning the blades, though. They’re super sharp.
- It’s a powerful blender selling at an attractive price
- 1,400-watt motor will turn peanuts into perfectly creamy nut butter
- Comes with 3 Auto-IQ presets
- Manual modes “Low” , “Med, “High”, and “Pulse” function give you full control over your blend
- Unique blade design helps you liquefy even tough ingredients
- Mostly made out of plastic, but doesn’t feel cheap
- The blades are very sharp, be cautious while cleaning them
- Warranty is short at only 1 year
General Opinion: With the latest-generation Ninja Professional Plus you can make perfectly delicious peanut butter. The 1,400-watt motor powers through everything you put into it. It comes with smart presets that take out all the guesswork.
2. Vitamix E310 – Affordable Commercial Blender
If you’ve ever researched blenders, you’ve probably heard of Vitamix. They manufacture some of the best blenders money can buy.
Thousands of restaurants and juice bars use Vitamix blenders, because of their powerful motors and sturdy design.
The Vitamix E310 Explorian is an entry-level model. It comes with a 48 oz, low-profile container that fits under most kitchen cabinets.
Just because it’s less expensive than most other Vitamix blenders doesn’t mean it’s less powerful than the more expensive models.
Vitamix really only uses two different motor sizes in its blenders.
They have the 2 horsepower motor and a 2.2 horsepower motor. There isn’t much difference between the two motor sizes in terms of blending power.
If you want the smoothest peanut butter possible, there’s no way around a commercial blender like a Vitamix.
The motor is so powerful that it can heat up cold ingredients in just a few minutes. It does that just with the friction of the blades!
You can make homemade, piping-hot soup just by adding veggies and a few spices to the blender jar and let it run for a few minutes. A blender that powerful surely has what it takes to make perfect peanut butter as well.
What are the differences between the Vitamix E310 and the more expensive models?
This entry-level model doesn’t have a fancy LCD display or any presets. It comes with the classic Vitamix design. There’s a manual speed dial, a switch for the pulse function and an on/off button. It doesn’t get much easier than that.
More expensive Vitamix models come with 7-year or even 10-year warranties, the E310 “only” has a 5-year warranty.
As with every Vitamix blender, built quality is as good as it can get. It’s assembled in the US and can last you for a lifetime.
- It’s one of the more affordable Vitamix blenders
- Comes with an incredibly powerful 2 horsepower motor
- Very easy to use
- Makes even smoother peanut butter than a Ninja blender
- Assembled in the US and built to last
- Comes with a full 5-year warranty
- Doesn’t come with presets
- A commercial blender like this costs more than most blenders
- A Vitamix is loud
General Opinion: If money is no concern, a Vitamix is the best blender for peanut butter. They come with powerful motors and are the most durable blenders out there. If you don’t need fancy presets, the Vitamix E310 might be right for you. It has the same blending functionality than higher-end models that cost twice as much.
3. Ninja BN801 Professional Plus – Blender & Food Processor
If you’re in need for a versatile kitchen helper that can make so much more than just peanut butter, this blender food processor combo is worth thinking about.
With the Ninja Professional Plus you get two smaller smoothie cups including secure lids, a full-size 72 oz blender jar, as well as a food processor bowl.
It comes with 5 different Auto-iQ presets for smoothies, crushing ice, juicing, chopping, and making dough. It allows you to create perfect results all at the touch of a button. The built-in timer shows you the precise blending time.
The motor has 1,400-watts of blending power. That’s more than enough to make perfect peanut butter.
You could use the smaller cups, the full-size jar, or even the food processor bowl for making nut butter, all will work fine. Ninja even includes some nut butter recipes inside the cute, colorful recipe booklet that comes with this blender.
- Compared to other all-in-one devices, the Ninja Professional Plus is inexpensive
- The 1,400-watt motor has enough power to create smooth peanut butter
- Comes with two smaller cups, a 72 oz jar, as well as a food processor bowl
- Don’t stop at peanut butter: blend, mix, chop, puree, or make dough all with just one device
- Built-in timer shows you the precise blending time
- Most parts are dishwasher safe for easy cleanup
- Only comes with a 1-year limited warranty
- This blender is louder than weaker standard blenders
- Some users report cracks on the jars
General Opinion: If you’re in need for a versatile device, the Ninja Professional Plus is a good choice. You can make everything from nut butters, dressings, purees, smoothies, chop veggies and more. You can blend in the full-size jar, the single-serve cups, or use the food processor bowl for most kitchen tasks.
4. Ninja Foodi – Blend & Cook
The Ninja Foods might be an overkill if you’re only using it to make peanut butter. This blender has all the blending power you expect from a Ninja, plus the ability to cook ingredients.
You’ve heard that right, this blender not only blends, it can cook!
You can make everything from frozen drinks, smoothies, nut butters, as well as hot soups, dips, and sauces.
How does the Ninja Foodi cook ingredients? It has a built-in heating element.
It heats up cold ingredients to steaming-hot in minutes. It does all that with the push of one button. Add cold ingredients like veggies and spices for a homemade, healthy soup. Press the Auto-iQ for soup and you can walk away. In just a few minutes the steaming-hot soup is ready.
It also has a heated self-cleaning mode. Just add some water, push a button and this blender will clean itself while you can do something else.
The Ninja Foodi comes with 12 Auto-iQ programs. Unfortuntately, it doesn’t have a preset for nut butter, but peanut butter isn’t difficult to make with this blender.
This blender has presets for smoothies, frozen drinks, soups, ice cream, sauces, and many more. In total it comes with 12 intelligent programs that use automated blending cycles.
If you’re making hot soups or sauces this blender automatically heats it up during the blending cycle. No guesswork involved.
The Ninja Food is one of the few Ninja blenders that comes with a tamper, so you won’t need to stop blending to scrape the sides. You can easily push ingredients down while blending. The tamper is perfect for smoothies with a thicker consistency or nut butters.
What I love about the Ninja Foodi is the glass pitcher.
Blenders with a glass jar are rare these days. A glass jar won’t leach nasty chemicals into your blend. It also won’t absorb food smells and you can wash it at higher temperatures.
Downside to the Ninja Foodi is that the jar is pretty heavy. You also shouldn’t submerge the jar in water because of the built-in heating element. Always wash it carefully and follow the instructions in the manual.
- The 1,400-watt motor is powerful
- The tamper works great for making peanut butter
- 12 Auto-iQ presets take out all the guesswork
- This blender not only blends, it can cook!
- The built-in timer shows you the precise blending time
- One of the few blenders with a durable glass jar
- The glass jar with the heating element is heavy
- You shouldn’t submerge the jar in water because of the heating element
- Ninja blenders only come with a 1-year limited warranty
General Opinion: The Ninja Foodi is so much more than just a blender for peanut butter. With this blender you can cook! No matter if you want to make hot sauces, dips, or soups, it’ll get it done. Simply add the ingredients, choose one of the 12 presets and you can walk away while the Ninja Foodi does all the work for you.
5. Nutri Ninja – Best Personal Blender for Peanuts
If you’re in need for a small blender for making peanut butter, the Nutri Ninja Pro is a good choice. This blender has been around for a few years and stood the test of time. It’s the perfect blender if your kitchen space is limited.
The Nutri Ninja comes with two blending cups, one 18 oz and one 24 oz jar.
There’s always a battle between the NutriBullet 900 and the Nutri Ninja Pro. In my opinion, the Nutri Ninja wins it by miles. The Nutri Ninja is more affordable and versatile.
The Nutri Ninja breaks down ice into snow-like consistency in seconds, the NutriBullet just won’t do that. It’s not that the motor of the NutriBullet is weak, but the blade design isn’t as efficient as it could be.
The Nutri Ninja’s blade design is genius. You can even make silk-smooth smoothies with this small device. The 900-watt motor breaks down peanuts and turns them into smooth peanut butter in no time.
Downside to the Nutri Ninja Pro is that it doesn’t run hands-free. You’ll have to push down the jar to keep it running. Ninja blenders also only come with a 1-year warranty. I’ve had my Nutri Ninja Pro for a few years, use it daily, and it’s still going strong.
- The Nutri Ninja Pro is inexpensive
- Makes perfectly smooth peanut butter
- The 900-watt motor is powerful
- Comes with two durable, thick plastic cups in different sizes
- Doesn’t run hands-free
- The 1-year limited warranty is short
General Opinion: The Nutri Ninja Pro is the perfect blender for peanut butter if you want a small blender. It fits even in the smallest kitchens. The 900-watt motor is powerful and makes perfectly smooth peanut butter.
These were some of the best blenders for making peanut butter. I hope you found these reviews helpful and it has given you a good place to start your own research. What’s your favorite blender for peanuts? If you have any questions, I’ll be happy to answer them in the comment section below. Stay vibrant, happy & healthy!